| Year |
Champs |
| 1990 |
Bill Huff / George "Mr. Siena" Bruda |
| 1991 |
Bill Huff / Fred "The Cowboy" Seestadt |
| 1992 |
Dick Van Patten / Eric "Little E" Ostrovidski |
| 1993 |
Ed "The Killer" Miller / Len Prevost |
| 1994 |
Dave Matzner / Dean Herrick |
| 1995 |
Dick "1 arm" Van Patten / Sal Pirri |
| 1996 |
Bill Bobo / Dick Buyer |
| 1997 |
Ron Bigley / Dave Kutel |
| 1998 |
Al "Muhammed" Spencer / Hugh "2 shirts" Graber |
| 1999 |
Bill Bobo / Robb Field |
| 2000 |
Roger Cuva / Ed "The Killer" Miller |
| 2001 |
Bill Leonard / Hugh "2 shirts" Graber |
| 2002 |
John Bossung / Larry Miller |
| 2003 |
Dick "No arms" Van Patten / Mark "Mr. All Over" Pirri |
| 2004 |
Ed "My Arm Hurts" Miller / Ernie "The Hinder" Petitti |
| 2005 |
"Old" Mann Szeto / Rick "The Good Rick" Field Jr. |
| 2006 |
Ron "The Bags" Bigley / Mark "Mr. T" Abodeely |
| 2007 |
Bill Bobo / John Sarno |
| 2008 |
Dominic Bologna / Jason DeAngelis |
| 2009 |
Mark Abodeely / Bill Rosch |
| 2010 |
Mark Abodeely / Ron Bigley |
| 2011 |
?? / ?? |
| 2012 |
Kris Grimmer / Steve Thomson |
| 2016 |
Julio Colon / Tom Newman |